It usually comes in the very first phone screen, sometimes in the first five minutes: “So, what are your salary expectations?” I’ve asked that question hundreds of times from the hiring side of the table, and I can tell you exactly what happens next. The number you say becomes the anchor for everything that follows.
Why recruiters ask so early
It isn’t a trick. Recruiters ask because they need to know if you fit the budget before they spend time on more interviews. But your answer quietly sets the ceiling. Say a number that’s too low, and that’s often where the offer lands, even if the budget was higher.
Step 1: Ask for their range first
You have every right to know what the role pays. In Massachusetts, employers with 25 or more employees now have to include a pay range in job postings, and many other states have similar laws. If the range isn’t posted, ask for it.
“I’d love to make sure we’re aligned. Could you share the budgeted range for this role?”
Most recruiters will tell you. Once you know their range, you can aim for the upper part of it instead of guessing.
Step 2: If they push, give a researched range
Before any phone screen, know the market rate for your role, your level, and your city. Then give a range where the bottom number is the one you’d actually be happy with, not your bare minimum.
“Based on my research for similar roles in Boston and the experience I bring, I’m looking at somewhere in the $110,000 to $125,000 range, depending on the full package.”
Notice three things in that sentence. It’s based on market data, not on what you need. It mentions your experience. And “depending on the full package” leaves room to discuss bonus, equity, and benefits later.
Step 3: If it’s too early to say
If you don’t know enough about the role yet, it’s fine to say so, as long as you stay warm and flexible.
“I’d like to learn more about the scope and responsibilities first so I can give you a number that makes sense. I’m confident we can find something that works if I’m the right fit.”
What about your current salary?
In Massachusetts, it’s illegal for employers to ask about your salary history, and many other states have the same rule. You never have to share it. Keep the conversation on what the role is worth, not on what you earn today.
Online forms that demand a number
If an application won’t let you continue without a number, enter the midpoint of your researched range. Never enter a low number just to get through the form. Recruiters do read it.
Mistakes I see all the time
- Naming a number before you’ve done any research.
- Giving a range where the bottom is lower than you’d accept.
- Talking about your personal expenses instead of the market.
- Apologizing for your number, or adding “but I’m flexible” right away.
Here’s the insider truth: when a candidate answers calmly with a researched range, recruiters don’t see them as difficult. They see someone who knows their worth, and that’s exactly the kind of person hiring managers want to hire.
